|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o........................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x..............................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o.........................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x...............................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o.................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o..................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.............................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o....................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...............................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o....................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x............................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o.........................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o.................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox..................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.............................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o...........................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..........................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x...............340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o..............334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x......349 05...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.355 |
|
||||
|
||||
למרות שטור המספרים הימני זז עוד קצת ימינה, נמשכת מגמת הירידה במספר החולים בפועל וזה מעודד. |
|
||||
|
||||
הגענו לשיא הגל הראשון. 11 נפטרים ליום לעומת 10 ליום בשיא הגל הראשון (19 באפריל). נכון ללפני יומיים, כל המדדים ממשיכים לעלות בקפיצות קטנות למעט מספר הנשאים הפעילים שם יש ירידה משמעותית. הירידה הזו היא ככל הנראה מלאכותית. היא מורכבת מעלייה טבעית במספר המחלימים שתוגברה ע"י עוד מניפולציה של משהב"ר ששינה את הנהלים של בדיקת החלמה ולדעתי מכריז על אנשים שעודם מדבקים כנקיים. יחד אם זאת, קרוב לודאי שאנו כבר באזור המישור של שיא הגל ויש התייצבות בכל הפרמטרים. האם התמותה תמשיך לגדול בצעדים קטנטנים אל מעבר לגל הראשון או תתחיל לרדת, זאת נראה בימים הבאים. יש עוד שני נתונים שצריך להצביע עליהם. החרדים ממשיכים בקנאות להוביל בטבלת היישובים המפיצים ויחס הצעירים מבין החולים ממשיך לגדול בעקביות ומגיע כבר ל-30%. שני הנתונים כנראה קשורים. |
|
||||
|
||||
למה כוונת ב "הצעירים מבין החולים" (בסוף תגובתך). המספרים בבדיקות חסרי משמעות בעיני, בגלל השינויים המתמידים במדיניות הבדיקות. מבחינת הנשאות, להערכתי תמיד היו נשאים צעירים רבים, רק שאולי השתנתה צורת הבדיקות. לא חושב שהווירוס השתנה, מה שהשתנה הוא שהיום המגיפה התפשטה לציבור רחב. היום בערים ירוקות, לפחות 5 אחוז מהאוכלוסיה הם נשאים. מי שחושש לבריאותו צריך להקפיד בקנאות על ריחוק גופני והגיינה וכן מסיכות בחללים סגורים, שאר הדברים לא משמעותיים. לגבי התמותה. כבר העלתי את ההיפותזה שעומס החום הכבד מחמיר את המחלה (ואת התמותה), לפיכך בעוד חודש או חודשיים כאשר עומס החום ירד גם התחלואה הקשה והפטירות יצטמצמו. לא ברור לי שבבית חולים ניתן להקל על עומס חום כאשר הזרמת אוויר מיזוג אויר או וינטלטוטרים לצורך קירור היא פעולה שיוצרת הדבקה, אין פרטים בנידון לכן אני בערפל בעניין זה. |
|
||||
|
||||
אתה נשמע אדם צעיר שנעים להחליף איתו דעות, אבל משום מה נראה שאתה נוטה להיתפס לכל מיני "אמיתות" רדיקליות שכולם, מלבד הפאנאטים שהאמיתות האלו הם הקרדום לחפור בו שלהם, יודעים שאינן נכונות. ולהבדיל מדב שכבר שינה עמדתו בכל מיני זוטי דברים, יש חשש שלא קל יהיה להזיז אותך מדעתך. אני כרגע, עסוק מאד, ולכן רק אציין את השגיאות העובדתיות שלך. אל תראה בכך אגרסיביות או פסילה אישית. בעתיד אני אשתדל לפרט ולהתדיין יותר. א. "המספרים בבדיקות חסרי משמעות בעיני, בגלל השינויים המתמידים במדיניות הבדיקות" - אני אישית הגבתי רבות על השינויים והמניפולציות המרובות מדי שעושה משהב"ר. יחד עם זאת, המספרים הם מספרים. אי אפשר להתעלם מהם ולחפש מספרי קסם שהשלטון לא יכול לגעת בם. (ע"ע מס' מאושפזים, חולים קשה ואפילו מספרי מתים). ב. "תמיד היו נשאים צעירים רבים, רק שאולי השתנתה צורת הבדיקות" - שיטת הבדיקות בודאי השתנתה (לנצט) וממשיכה להשתנות לעיתים. ולכן % הנשאים הצעירים משתנה. בגל הראשון 10% מן המאובחנים היו מתחת לגיל 19. בגל השני התחילו עם 20% והמספר עולה לאט אך בצורה עקבית והוא כעת 30%. ג. לא חושב שהווירוס השתנה, מה שהשתנה הוא שהיום המגיפה התפשטה לציבור רחב" - הוירוס כנראה כן השתנה. המומחים יגידו מה ההגדרה המדוייקת, אבל הוירוס הפעיל בישראל כיום הוא קצת יותר מדבק וקצת פחות קטלני. זה חלק מן ההסבר מדוע מס' הנשאים בגל השני הוא פי 4 מאשר בגל הראשון ומס' המתים לעת עתה די דומה ו-% התמותה מבין המאושפזים ירד לחצי. (מעריך שזו הסיבה השנייה אחרי החפירה לתוך הקרחון ולפני השיפור בטיפול הרפואי). ד. "ההיפותזה שעומס החום הכבד מחמיר את המחלה (ואת התמותה)" - זו פעם ראשונה שאני שומע על התזה והיא נשמעת לי מופרכת. אם היה בכך משהו אפריקה, המזה"ת, ברזיל והודו היו הופכים לבית קברות אחד גדול. המחקר אומר שהקורונה מעדיפה את טווח הטמפרטורות והלחות של וירוסי השפעת והנזלת, אבל כבר נוכחנו שזו העדפה די שולית. |
|
||||
|
||||
ג. הקביעות על אחוז התמותה הנמוך מקדימות את זמנן. התמותה, כמו שראינו בגל הראשון, מתעכבת הרבה אחרי השאר, והתקווה שהיא תהיה פחות מאחוז אחד מהנדבקים נראית לי תקוות שווא. |
|
||||
|
||||
יכול להיות שבסוף שוב יתברר שאתה צודק. כרגע זה לא נראה כך. בסוף הגל הראשון % התמותה מתוך המטופלים התייצב על 1.8, כאשר לא ממש ברור לי מהי ההגדרה המדוייקת של מטופלים (cases, נראה לי שזה די קרוב למאושפזים). כפי שאמרת לוקח זמן עד שהגרף הזה מתייצב. בתחילת הגל השני הודיעו בטלביזיה שה-% ירד ל-0.8, אך העקומה ב-worldmeter סרבה להענות ונותרה במקומה. חלפו שבוע או שבועיים והעקומה החלה לרדת לאט אבל עקבי. הערך כרגע הוא 1.09 וממשיך לרדת (הנתון הוא מצטבר וכולל את הגל הראשון). אני מניח שזו ירידה אמיתית. כרגיל יתכנו כאן מניפולציות. למשל, נניח שמספר המיטות והפרוטוקול מאפשר אשפוז של חולים קלים יותר. יחד עם זאת הירידה משמעותית ואני מעריך שהזמינות של תרופות אנטי-ויראליות והחיבור המאוחר יותר של חולים למנשמים עושים את שלהם. |
|
||||
|
||||
לגבי הסתמכות על מספרים של ניבדקי נשאות (נידמה לי שקוראים להם "חולים מאומתים"). ברגע שהתברר שהניבדקים הם לא מקבוצה רנדומלית, אלא מקבוצות פרטניות בהתאם למצב (נניח , בדיקה שמרוכזת בתלמידי בתי ספר , או תלמידי ישיבות ) , הרי אין שום ערך להסיק איזושהיא מסקנה מהמספרים לגבי איפיונים של המחלה. (אולי אילו שמארגנים את הבדיקות עושים זאת מתוך כוונה מוצדקת , אבל הכוונה הזו נעלמה מעינינו). הטענה שהווירוס בישראל פועל בצורה שונה מקודמו , על סמך " דעת מומחים" לא משכנעת אותי. המומחים אמרו הרבה דברים שהתבדו. לכן אין לי סיבה להאמין להם הפעם. המחלה לא מוכרת, מוטב להכיר בכך. אם אמנם יש יותר הידבקויות, יכולות להיות לכך סיבות אחרות, דוגמא: אנשים רבים היום אינם מרגישים שהם בסיכון אפילו יחלו לכן מעדיפים לזלזל בהוראות. איני טוען שדווקא הטענה האחרונה נכונה, אני רק טוען שאי אפשר להסיק מסקנות כאשר הנתונים מאוד ברורים. עד כאן בנוגע ל א. ו- ב. . דילגתי על ג. לגבי ד. ההיפותזה שעומס חום גדול לו על הגוף יכול להעלות תמותה לגמרי לא מופרכת. היה לפני שנים רבות גל חום עצום באירופה וביוון היה גל תמותה מוגבר בעקבותיו. אדם בריא יכול להתגבר על עומס חום, אני למשל עושה מיקלחת קרה ומייד מרגיש הקלה. לאדם חולה, במיוחד אם הוא מאושפז ולא אדון לגופו, אין הרבה אופציות להקל על גופו , הוא תלוי בטיב הטיפול הסיעודי בבית החולים ולעיתים הטיפול הסיעודי שם חלש. אני זוכר שכאשר אבי היה מאושפז במצב קשה הוא נחשף להיפותרמיה (לא כיסו אותו בשמיכות), זאת מכיוון שאף כוח עזר סיעודי לא טיפל בו. לבסוף כאשר באתי לביקור השגתי עבורו שמיכה. החלשה של הגוף בגין מועקה גופנית (שאינה זיהומית אלא סיעודית) מחלישה את כוחו של הגוף להתגונן. מקובל בעניין שפעת, שכאשר אדם חולה בשפעת — טיפול סיעודי טוב משפר את סיכויי ההחלמה. נראה לי שאותו כלל חל על כל מחלה קשה. תשומת ליבי לעניין עומס החום והקורלציה שלו לתמותה הופנתה בתחילת יולי (נידמה מ- 7 יולי ואילך). באותם ימים הופיעו גלי חום כבדים במדינה ובו זמנית מספר הניפטרים קפץ פי כמה. כל מה שאני אומר לגבי עומס חום מכוון רק למה שקורה בבתי חולים. אנשים חולים בביתם, או בביקתותיהם באפריקה , יכולים להתמודד טוב יותר עם עומס החום גם אם האקלים שם קשה, כי הם אדונים על גופם ויכולים להקל על עצמם בלי להיות תלויים באחרים, לפחות אם יש לידם בני משפחה. |
|
||||
|
||||
עכשיו הבנתי את כוונתך בקשר לעומס החום. אכן עומס חום בשילוב כל מחלה קשה כנראה אינם חדשות טובות. בכל מקרה, בישראל יחסית מעט מאד אנשים מתים מקורונה ולכן ההסבר הנדרש הוא מדוע התמותה נמוכה כל כך ולא להיפך. |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o........................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x..............................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o.........................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x...............................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o.................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o..................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.............................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o....................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...............................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o....................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x............................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o.........................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o.................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox..................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.............................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o...........................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..........................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x...............340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o..............334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x......349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........345 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x..................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o.......................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x...................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox..................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o.......................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...............................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.......................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o....................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.....................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..............................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.............................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x..................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.........................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o................345 07......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.374 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o......................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o......................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..............................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...........................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x............................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o...............................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.....................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.............................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o...............................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...............374 08.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.389 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....389 09..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.394 |
|
||||
|
||||
סליחה על האחור. פשוט שכחתי. גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.397 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.................381 |
|
||||
|
||||
תראו מה זה: רק החליטו על בחירות חדשות וכבר מספר החולים הקשים התחיל לרדת! גאון, הנתניהו הזה. |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...................379 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o...............379 13..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............386 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o...............379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...........386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....................377 |
|
||||
|
||||
הייתי רוצה להציג 2 שאלות למגיבים עם יותר ידע ממני: א. בעניין החיסון הרוסי: ברור שהוא פתוח בהליך שקיצר כל נוהל הכרחי בדרך. השאלה המטרידה אותי היא אם באמת תרופות שעברו בקרה מסודרת במשך אפילו עד עשר שנים הם באמת בטוחים או אפקטיביים יותר מתרופות מזורזות, אפילו בנוסח הרוסי? נראה שיש שם הרבה פרנסה לפקידים, ועדות ופרוטוקלים. האם כל זה מבטיח יותר ביטחון, תמהני. ב. האם יש מחקרים אמינים על התועלת והאפקטיביות של החיסונים לשפעות שניתנים בשנים האחרונות. מידע אישי נראה שקשה מאד למדוד את האפקטיביות. יש יותר מדי תירוצים (זנים חדשים, תקופת קליטה ארוכה עד שהחיסון פעיל). |
|
||||
|
||||
א. אין לי ידע מסודר בנושא, אבל נראה לי שההליך הארוך נכון. כשאתה נותן חיסונים לכלל האוכלוסיה אתה חייב לדעת את ההשפעות קצרות הטווח וארוכות הטווח שלהם. לדוגמה- החיסון האורלי לפוליו יגרום למחלת הפוליו אצל המתחסן בשיעור של אחד למיליון. לכן נמנעים מלתת את החיסון האורלי כשאין סכנה להתפרצות המגפה. לעומת זאת בהודו, בגלל התנאים, המשיכו לתת את החיסון האורלי ולקחת את הסיכון כדי להדביר את המגפה. אתה חייב לעשות את שלב III על כמות גדולה של נבדקים כדי לדעת גם את הסיכון הקטן. במקרה של הקורונה אולי משתלם לקחת את הסיכון במדינות שהמגפה משתוללת בהן מתוך הערכה שהמחיר בחיי אדם של קיצור התהליך יהיה נמוך מהמחיר בחיי אדם של הגעה מאוחרת לשוק. יחס העלות/תועלת יהיה בכל מקרה טוב יותר מזה של שתיית אקונומיקה. ב. ככל שאני יודע, החיסון לשפעת הוא מאוד אפקטיבי. לפעמים הוא מפספס את הזן המדויק (צריך לנחש מראש לפי הטרנדיות של הזנים בחצי הכדור הדרומי) ואז ההגנה שהוא נותן היא חלשה, אבל ברוב המקרים פוגעים בזנים הנכונים וההגנה שלו מצויינת. אלמלא החיסונים לשפעת בתי החולים היו נכנסים לבעיה רצינית כל דצמבר. |
|
||||
|
||||
בכתבה כלשהי שציטטה ביקורות של מומחים על החיפזון מהשטן ממוסקבה, הוזכר איזשהו חיסון עבר שהתברר כי גרם במפתיע להגדלת התמותה מהזיהום נגדו היה אמור להגן. זה פחות מפתיע ממה שנשמע אם לוקחים בחשבון שלפעמים (דוגמה בולטת: קורונה) מה שהורג בזיהום קטלני הוא תגובת יתר של המערכת החיסונית. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני חושב שאין חולק על כך שהחיסון הרוסי פותח בהליך בלתי אמין בעליל. התהייה שלי היא האם ההליכים והפרוטוקולים המלאים, באמת מספקים את הסחורה. מה שקרה בעבר הוא שנזק של תרופות וחיסונים מתגלה שנים רבות אחרי שהתחילו להשתמש בהם. אני מנסה להזיז את נקודת המבט, חמש שנים קדימה, ולשאול האם יהיה הבדל משמעותי באפקטיביות וסיכונים בין החיסון הרוסי לבין החיסון של מודרנה או אוקספורד? ברור שיש סיכוי שהחיסון הרוסי יתברר כהונאה מביכה, אבל נדמה לי שהסיכוי הוא די גדול שגם החיסונים האחרים יתבררו כלא אפקטיביים, למרות כל האישורים והועדות. הסיבה שאני מעיז לומר זאת הוא שאת כל הבדיקות והניסויים לפי הפרוטוקולים הנדרשים, מנהלים ומממנים החברות המפתחות בעצמן ולא ה-FDA או WHO כפי שנוטים לחשוב. |
|
||||
|
||||
אבל זה תמיד המצב. ה־FDA הוא גורם מפקח. |
|
||||
|
||||
בהחלט. לכן גם שאלתי על חיסוני השפעת השייכים לעבר הרחוק של העידן שלפני הקורונה. אחרי שראינו כולנו את מידת הסמכותיות שבה אנשי המדע מדבררים הצהרות שהן בעלות אמינות של קוראות בקלפים, אולי צריך לפתוח גם את הנושא של חיסוני השפעת. האם הם באמת יעילים? האם התמותה משפעת פחתה מאז שהחל החיסון ההמוני? האם נערכו מחקרים מבוססים סטטיסטית שבדקו את האפקטיביות של החיסונים? אני רוצה לציין שאיני סיינטולוג ואיני מתנגד לחיסונים. אני רק שואל. |
|
||||
|
||||
כדי להטיל ספק בהפצת מידע על ידי גופים רפואיים כגון FDA או who , די לזכור את האזהרות נגד שפעת החזירים. לגבי שפעת. אינני בטוח כלל ביעילות גבוהה של חיסוני שפעת, כי ידוע שווירוסים של שפעת הם בעלי כושר השתנות גבוה משנה לשנה (בלי להכנס לשאלה המדעית מה בדיוק משתנה שם). כאשר השוני של זני שפעת משנה לשנה מנטרלת את האפקטיביות של החיסון. אני מסרב לקחת חיסון לשפעת דווקא משום שכל שנה קופת חולים שולחת לי ספאם לגבי החיסון , זה יוצר אצלי הרגשה שחיסוני שפעת מקודמים על ידי חברות התרופות מטעמים מסחריים (הטעמים המסחריים הם כאילו שאותם אני לא מבין). מה שמעורר אצלי התנגדות זו תופעת הספאם כשלעצמה. היו עוד תופעות בנוגע לקורונה שבגללו אין לי אימון רב במערכת הרפואית. אחת התופעות היא שלילה חריפה של הטיפול בהידרוכלורופין +אבץ + אנטי ביוטיקה שמבוסס על מחקר כושל (שפירסומו נימשך אחורה לאחר הפירסום). למזלי יש לי מערכת חיסונית חזקה, לא חליתי בשפעת או כל מחלה זיהומית אחרת כבר עשרות שנים. לכן אני יכול להרשות לעצמי להמנע מחיסונים. בכל מקרה לא אקח חיסון נגד קורונה לפני שהיא תיבחן בחיסון המוני לפחות משך שנה. זאת כדי להשתכנע שלחיסון אין תופעות לוואי משמעותיות. |
|
||||
|
||||
הידרוקסיכלורוקווין לא נמצאה כתרופה יעילה לקורונה. מספר לא מבוטל של מחקרים הראה שהיא לא יעילה בטיפול בקורונה. בהתחשב בתופעות הלוואי שלה, זה גרם לחוסר ההמלצה עליה. אבל היה גם מחקר מזויף שהתיימר להראות שהיא מסוכנת. המחקר הזה התגלה מהר מאוד על ידי הקהילה המדעית כלא אמין ולא מתחשבים בתוצאותיו. כלומר: ישלה תופעות לוואי בעייתיות, אבל הן אינן חדשות. חיסון לשפעת אינו יעיל בכמעט 100% כמו חיסונים אחרים, אבל מפחית את התפשטות השפעת: הוא יעיל בכמעט 100% כנגד חלק מזני השפעת הנפוצים. לכן התחסנות עוזרת ליצירת חיסון עדר נגד אותם זני שפעת. כלומר: אתה עצמך בריא ולא תחלה, אבל תפחית את הסיכון של אחרים בסביבתך שבריאים פחות לחלות. קופות החולית באות מהפוזיציה. הן קמצניות ורוצות להשקיע כמה שפחות כסף על טיפול בחולי שפעת. אם קופת חולים כללית הייתה יכולה ליצור חיסון עדר למבוטחי כללית בלבד, הא הייתה עושה את זה. אבל מכיוון שזה לא מעשי, היא מעדיפה לעודד את כל האנשים להתחסן. |
|
||||
|
||||
אם להתייחס לשורה הראשונה שלך כעדות לחוסר התועלת של הפרוצדורה המלאה שהזכרתי, הרי אין שום עדות לכך שהפרוצדורה המלאה לא הצליחה. בשורה הראשונה אתה מדבר על שימוש ההידרוכלורוקוין כתרופה יחידה בפרוצדורה לבדיקה. אחת הטענות המרכזיות של ממליצים על הפרוצדורה, לטיבה של הפרוצדורה, היא שיש לבצע אותה _במלואה_. ביצוע חלק מהפרוצדורה אינו מוכיח דבר. בעקרון, ההידרוכלורופין אמור לשמש מעין מזרק סופר מיקרוסקופי להזרקת אבץ לתוך התאים, כאשר האבץ הוא החומר האקטיבי שפועל נגד הווירוס של קורונה. ההידרוכלורוקוין לבדו אינו החומר שתוקף את הוירוס, הוא כאמור רק המזרק. הוספת אנטיביוטיקה לקוקטיל בפרוצדורה השלימה אינו פועל על וירוס הקורונה אלא על זיהומים חיידקיים מישניים שנוצרים אצל רוב חולי הקורונה. בפרסום בברייבארט , איות לא בטוח, (שעליהם טוענים שהם לא מהימנים) — רופאה בבית חולים, לא זוכר איפה, מעידה שנתנו את הפרוצדורה _המלאה_ בערך ל- 850 מאושפזים שחלו בקורונה ואף אחד מהם לא מת. החיסון ניתן מייד, לא לאחר שהיו במצב קשה. זה נתון מרשים מאוד (אם הוא נכון) ומוכיח יעילות ללא ספק, שכן מקרב חולי קורונה מאושפזים יש אחוז גבוה של מתים. לא חישבתי אחוזים כי אין נתונים בארץ מלבד מספר הניפטרים מקורונה עד היום, 600 כמדומני. באומדן מאוד גס --- לא חושב שאושפזו בארץ בבתי חולים יותר מ- 6000 חולי קורונה עד היום. רק כדי לסבר את האוזן, זה אומר לפחות 10 אחוז מהמאושפזים בקורונה ניפטרים. לא ניתקלתי בשום מקום בטענה על מחקר שנעשה לגבי יעילות הפרוצדורה המלאה, לרבות טיפול בקוקטיל הנ"ל בשלבים הראשונים של הופעת הסימפטומים. (אם הפרוצדורה לא בולמת את המחלה אפשר לעבור לטיפולים אלטרנטיביים, לכן אין פה הגברת סיכון של העדר טיפול). |
|
||||
|
||||
יש עדויות. נעשו ניסוים מסודרים. ניסויים עם בקרה. לא סתם נתונים שרופא משליך לאוויר. |
|
||||
|
||||
לא שמעתי על ניסויים. זה שאתה אומר שהיו ניסויים לא אומר שהיו. בעקבות תגובתי בדקתי היום בגוגל. והגעתי לניסוי של יותר מ- 10000 איש שהסתיים באפריל, נדמה לי 20 אפריל. הניסוי בדק רק שימוש בהידרוכלורקסיקוין, ללא התוספת של אבץ (או חומר אנטי ויראלי אחר). המסקנה מהניסוי היא שהידרוכלוקסיקוין לבדו לא מועיל ולא מזיק, ושצריך להמשיך ניסוי עם תוספת אבץ (או תוספת חומר אקטיבי אחר). לא פגשתי בפרסום על מחקר המשך המומלץ על ידי עורכי המחקר הגדול. כמו שאמרתי, ניסוי בהידרוכלורקסיקוין לבדו הוא ניסוי חסר משמעות והתייחסות לניסוי משובש כאל ניסוי הוא הטעיה. |
|
||||
|
||||
לפי ה־CDC: 1. החיסונים יעילים, אבל יעילותם שונה נגד זני שפעת שונים, וכמוכן לפי ההצלחה לחזות מראש את תתי הזנים שיגיעו בעונה הנוכחית. 2. אין שם תשובה. אני חושב שהתשובה לשאלה הזו מושפעת גם מיעילות הטיפול. 3. כן. |
|
||||
|
||||
אלו גם המספרים שאני זוכר (מדיווחים בעיתונות, לא קראתי מחקרים ישירים) - כחמישים אחוז בשנים 'מוצלחות' וכ-25 אחוז בשנים פחות מוצלחות. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני אנסה לחדד איתך מה בדיוק השאלה. גם אם ה-FDA עושה את תפקידו על הצד הטוב ביותר, והניסויים מתנהלים לפי מיטב הפרוטוקולים, ססטיסטית יגיעו לפעמים לשוק תרופות וחיסונים לא מועילים, ואף מזיקים. הייתי מסתפק בכך שהרגולציה מצליחה להוריד את הסיכון בסדר גודל, לעומת מצב היפותטי שבו השוק פועל בערך כמו החיסון הרוסי (לכאורה). אולי צריך להגדיר יותר במדויק את המצב ההיפותטי הזה, אבל כרגע אני מתעצל ואשאיר את זה עמום. למצוא נימוקים אמפיריים ישירים זה קשה, אבל אני רוצה לטעון שכן (הם מורידים סיכון בסדר גודל), על-ידי הסקה משתי טענות שאני מקווה שנוכל להסכים על שניהם. (1) ה-FDA אפקטיבי בפיקוח על התעשייה, ומצליח לעמוד בפרץ האינרטסים הכלכליים העצומים (וקצרי הטווח). זה אולי סוג של נס, אבל העדויות לזה פרושות לאורך ולרוחב העיתונות הכלכלית. תרופות אכן נגנזות (כולל, אגב, כאלו שנועדו לקורונה ויוצרו על-ידי ענקיות), ולא זכורות לי שערוריות בכיוון הזה. מעניין להשוות את זה לחוסר האפקטיביות המפורסם של הרגולציה האקדמית על פרסום בעיתונות המדעית - כמה מסקנות שגויות ומחקרים גרועים מתפרסמים ומצוטטים, והקהילה המדעית עדיין בשלב של גישושים וחיפושי דרך איך לשפר את המצב. (2) הפרוטוקולים בפני עצמם אפקטיביים. את זה אני מבקש לקבל מתוך אמונתנו במתודולוגיה המדעית. אם כי זה לא יספיק לנו כדי לקבל אומדן כמותי לתועלת, בלי שהגדרנו יותר במדויק מה המצב האלטרנטיבי. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני משער שמקבלי החיסון בתחילה יהיו אנשי רפואה ואולי גם חלק מכוחות הבטחון, כך שבעצם מה שמתבצע ברוסיה הוא כפייה של השתתפות בשלב השלישי של הניסוי. לשמחתנו משהו כזה לא יכול לקרות בעולם המערבי. |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o...............379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...........386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........387 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o..............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o...................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o.....................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x..........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o.......................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox...394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o...........381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o...............379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...........386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o..............377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o...........387 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..396 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x...........................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...............................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x...........................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...............................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.......................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...............................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o....................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.....................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o............................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..............................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o......................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.....................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x..........................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.........................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x...........................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o........................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.........389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox....394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o............381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x............386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...............377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o............387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.398 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.410 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x410 19.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..........401 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x410 19.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.....401 20...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........403 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x410 19.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.....401 20..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......403 21......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....................390 |
|
||||
|
||||
היום אני יוצא לרחוב להפגין נגד הטיפול הכושל במשבר ונגד הכשלון המתמשך של הממשלה לדאוג לאזרחיה. אני קורא לממשלה ובמיוחד לראש הממשלה להתאפס על עצמם ולהתחיל לשים את טובת המדינה במקום הראשון משעה 17:30 עד 19:30 בצומת פרויד/ולנברג בחיפה עם דגלי המדינה ודגלים שחורים. כולם מוזמנים להשתתף |
|
||||
|
||||
יש הרבה מן המשותף בקריאה למצוא "פתרון" לבעיית רצועת עזה, ולקריאה למצוא פתרון לבעיית הקורונה. כמו שבעזה איני מאמין בפתרונות זולת כיבוש הרצועה, שהוא מעשה לא פשוט שמחייב הרבה קרבנות וגם כמה שנות סבל, כך גם איני מאמין בפתרונות קסם בנושא המגיפה שבהם הציבור לא חש בנטל, ומצפה מהממשלה שתמצא לו "פתרון". בתגובה אחרת ספרתי לך על הצעדים הקשים שנקטה ממשלת דרום קוריאה כתגובה להתפרצות של 150 אנשים ביממה בבירה סיאול. שם הציבור מקבל את הגזירה וקרוב לוודאי שהבעיה שם תיפתר במהרה. יכול מאד להיות שההצלחה בבלימת הגל הראשון באה בשל כך שאיך שהוא הצליחו להחדיר ללבות הצבור שקיימת סכנה גדולה, ובגלל הפחד הוא נהג באחריות. ואילו בגל השני לבו של הציבור היה גס בצעדים שצריך לנקוט. בזמן שבו הגל הראשון שכח והיינו בתקופה של ירידה מתמדת בתחלואה אמר ראש הממשלה שעלינו להיות עם היד על הדופק וברגע שיתגלו 100 נשאים חיוביים יהיה צריך לשוב ולחזור להגבלות משמעותיות. אבל ראש הממשלה לא קיים את מה שהוא עצמו אמר שצריך לעשות, וקשה להאשים אותו. הציבור שלנו הוא לא הציבור של דרום קוריאה. אנחנו נעשה מה שמתחשק לנו, ואתם, הממשלה, תמצאו לנו פתרון. ואם לא יימצא הפתרון נלך ונפגין עם או בלי זהירות למנוע הדבקות. אין זו אחריות שלנו. אתם אחראים. |
|
||||
|
||||
שכחתי להוסיף את חלקם של לנצט ודומיו למחדל. ההתנהגות השאננה של הציבור שהיא הגורם העיקרי, לדעתי, להתפרצות המחודשת, בוודאי חוזקה על ידי הפרסומים של לנצט לס בין ישראל ואחרים, ויש גם להם חלק לא קטן במחדל. |
|
||||
|
||||
הציבור הישראלי גם אשם במחדל הכלכלי? יש מעל 20% אבטלה. האם גם בכך קשה להאשים את ראש הממשלה? איך הציבור הישראלי גרם למחדל הזה? |
|
||||
|
||||
הפגיעה בכלכלה היא חלק ממשבר הקורונה. כך זה גם במדינות אחרות. |
|
||||
|
||||
לא ענית על השאלה. התחמקת. במדינות אחרות, בהן מתמודדים היטב עם המשבר, אין אבטלה של מעל 20%. של מי האחריות לכך אם לא של הממשלה? להגיד ״אבל קורונה״ לכל ביקורת זאת תגובה לא רצינית. מה אם נגיע ל 30% אבטלה או 40% גם אז תשתמש באותו הטיעון ״אבל קורונה פגעה בכלכלה של מדינות אחרות״? איזה דבר רע יכול להתרחש לכלכלת ישראל כדי שתגיד שהממשלה עושה משהו לא בסדר? יש לך דוגמה למשהו כזה? |
|
||||
|
||||
אני מאשים את הממשלה באזלת יד בדברים שבתחום אחריותה קשה להאשים אותם שהסגר היה ארוך ודפק את הכלכלה? שיצאנו ממנו בצורה הכי פרטצ'ית בעולם (עובדתית, לא כמטבע לשון) וכל השגיו נמחקו, אבל כל מחירו הכבד נשאר איתנו? שמערכת החינוך עדיין לא מוכנה לפתיחת שנת הלימודים אחרי שהיתה להם חצי שנה להתכונן? שהממשלה לא ערכה אפילו דיון אחד בנושא? שאנחנו באמצע אוגוסט ואין תקציב?! המדינה נמצאת במשבר הכלכלי הגדול ביותר מאז 1985 ואין תקציב. בעיני לא יכולה להיות לזה שום חוץ מאשר שרוב חברי הממשלה לא שמים את טובת המדינה במקום הראשון של מערכת השיקולים שלהם. |
|
||||
|
||||
כן. קשה להאשים את הממשלה בסגר. ללא הוא היינו עם אלפי מתים כפי שהיה באיטליה ספרד ובריטניה. וכשיש סגר הכלכלה נדפקת. אין מה לעשות. זו הברירה הטובה מבין הרעות. לדעתי, יצאנו ממנו בסדר, אבל הציבור לא הקפיד על התנהגותו כפי שהורו לו, והממשלה לא הקפידה על כך שהציבור יקפיד די, וגם לא לחצנו על הבלם ברגע שהיה צריך לעשות זאת, כפי שנעשה זה עתה בסיאול, וכפי שעשו בסין בכל פעם שהנגיף התעורר. במידה רבה האופי שלנו שמתבטא בחוסר צייתנות ובזלזול בהוראות, תופעות שהוגברו, לדעתי מאד, על ידי חלק מה''מומחים'', הוא שגרם לנזק. זו גם הסיבה לכך שהממשלה חוששת להפעיל צעדים כואבים אך נדרשים. עיקר המאבק במגיפה הוא בצעדים שהממשלה עושה דרך הציבור, והוא לא עמד במבחן. הביקורת מאד דומה לביקורת על הטיפול בבעית עזה. ברגע שהמבקרים יהיו בעמדת מחליטים, הם ייעשו בדיוק את אותו דבר, כפי שמוכיחים גנץ וכחול לבן. על הקטע שאין תקציב בינתיים, איני יודע עד כמה הדבר גורם נזק, אבל זה לא עיקר העניין שמדברים על המלחמה במגיפה. |
|
||||
|
||||
>> זו גם הסיבה לכך שהממשלה חוששת להפעיל צעדים כואבים אך נדרשים. אני יורק על ממשלה שזו הסיבה שהיא לא מפעילה צעדים כואבים אך נדרשים. ממשלה של פחדנים! |
|
||||
|
||||
>> על הקטע שאין תקציב בינתיים, איני יודע עד כמה הדבר גורם נזק, אבל זה לא עיקר העניין שמדברים על המלחמה במגיפה. מה?? |
|
||||
|
||||
״אין מה לעשות. זו הברירה הטובה מבין הרעות.״ לא נכון. מתברר שזאת הברירה הגרועה ביותר. הרע שבכל העולמות. הדרך הזאת מאפשרת לקבל תוצאות חיוביות *מדומות* בתחילת הדרך, להרוס את הכלכלה בצורה מהירה וקיצונית עד כדי כך עד שאמון הציבור במערכת מתערער לחלוטין והפוליטיקאים נאלצים להכנע ללחצי המשק לפתוח את המשק כמעט לחלוטין לפני שהכל יקרוס לחלוטין. זה שאתה עדיין תומך ברעיון הגרוע הזה מראה שהכישלון המוחלט של הממשלה שלנו הוא לא עניין טכני או שנובע מבלבול פוליטי. הכשלון של הממשלה הזאת לטפל במשבר הוא בשל בחירות אידיאולוגיות של הימין ותפיסת מציאות עקומה. קפיצה מתמדת בין תגובה קיצונית אחת לשניה ורידוד המציאות לפרמטר אחד שצריך להתמודד איתו ואיתו בלבד במערכת מרובת משתנים. במקום שיהיה מישהו אחראי על ההגה - יש אנשים כמוך שרוצים לשבור עם ההגה לכיוון אחד ואז הנוסעים המבוהלים שרואים שפונים לתהום שמים מיד את ידם על ההגה ושוברים לכיוון השני וככה יותר מידי אנשים על ההגה שוברים מקיצוניות אחת לשניה. בריטניה?! תלכלכו ותצחקו על מדינות אחרות כמה שאתם רוצים בגלל איזה גרף דבילי שהראה שבישראל המצב כאילו טוב יותר לכמה שבועות. העובדה היא שהמצב בבריטניה טוב יותר מהמצב בישראל, נקודה. פתרונות דביליים של סגר מלא, שמראים תוצאה חיובית בנתון ספציפי אחד בטווח הקצר, בלי התחשבות בכל הנתונים האחרים, זאת לא דרך לנהל מדינה. אפילו חנות מכולת לא הייתי נותן לך או לביבי לנהל. |
|
||||
|
||||
תוצאות חיוביות מדומות זו הגדרה קולעת. אנחנו כמו רץ מרתון שרץ את הקילומטר הראשון בכל הכח, נפנף בידיים וטפח על החזה והתרברב שהוא משיג את כולם, אבל כשהתברר שהמרתון לא מסתיים אחרי קילומטר, כבר לא נשאר לו אוויר וכולם עוקפים אותו. מה שפאתטי זה שחלק מהאנשים עוד מזכירים לחיוב ומתפארים בהובלה שלו באותו קילומטר ראשון כשאחרי עשרה קילומטר כבר ברור כשמש שהרץ שלנו הוא אצן מרתון כושל ועלוב. |
|
||||
|
||||
רציתי עוד להוסיף שכל הביקורת על אי יציאה נאותה מהסגר, היא חכמה שבדיעבד. את הביקורת הזאת היה ראוי לומר אז כשהתחלואה ירדה ולנצט אמר שהכול מאחורינו וצריך לפתוח הכול ולא לחשוש משום דבר. הראה לי שהייתה לך ביקורת מהסוג הזה אז. היום זה לא חכמה. |
|
||||
|
||||
לא היו לי ציפיות גבוהות מהממשלה תגובה 715478 29/3 אבל היא הצליחה לאכזב אותי מאוד בכל זאת. מבחינתי אפשר היה לשחרר את הסגר באופן מבוקר מיד אחרי פסח ובהחלט היה מובן אם היו מחכים שבוע נוסף תגובה 715406 מ 29/3 הביקורת שלי בזמן אמת היתה בתגובה 717779 23/4 ותגובה 718155 28/4. שתיהן הופנו אליך. אמרתי מראש שצריך לפתוח את הגנים והיסודיים ולחכות עם התיכונים! |
|
||||
|
||||
אתה רק מוכיח את מה שאני טוען. מה שאמרתי, או לפחות שלכך התכוונתי, הוא שבזמן שהמגיפה נבלמה והתחלואה הלכה ופחתה, לא שמענו ממך ביקורת על כך שהיציאה מההגבלות נעשתה בצורה לא נכונה ובגלל זה צפוי גל נוסף שהממשלה תהיה אחראית לו. לנצט נשא את משלו בערך חודש אחר שיא המגיפה, כשהתחלואה הייתה בירידה זמן רב, ומעט לפני ההתפרצות החדשה, וטען שהכול מאחורינו, אפשר לפתוח הכל, ולא לחשוש מדבר. מבין התגובות שלך שאתה מציג, אולי רק תגובתך מה 29 במרץ, שנכתבה כשבועיים אחרי שיא המגיפה, רלוונטית מבחינת התאריך שבו נכתבה. ומה הביקורת שלך בה? אתה אומר שם שלא היה צריך לפתוח את המספרות, אבל את מערכת החינוך היה צריך לפתוח מזמן. ככה היינו בולמים את התפרצות הגל השני (שכידוע החל במערכת החינוך). . . נו באמת. |
|
||||
|
||||
תיקון: התכוונתי כמובן לתגובתך מה 28 באפריל. |
|
||||
|
||||
הנקודה הבסיסית היא פתיחה מדורגת עם משוב. לפתוח קצת, לראות מה קורה, ולשקול את הצעדים לפי זה. זה לא מה שקרה בישראל. בישראל לא היה ניהול מסודר של הפתיחה: מערכון הגרלת הפיס של המגבלות בזהו־זה התייחס אמנם לשלב הסגירה השני, אבל התאים גם לשלב הפתיחה. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני מבקש גם ממך מה שבקשתי מאריק. חכמה בדיעבד אינה חכמה. |
|
||||
|
||||
חכמה בדיעבד היא בהחלט חכמה. זה מה שאנשים חכמים עושים - מעדכנים את הניואנסים של הדעות שלהם על פי הנתונים, גם בדיעבד אם צריך. |
|
||||
|
||||
ראה צפריר מסוף אפריל תגובה 717349. לא רק בדיעבד (וזו רק דוגמא אחת). |
|
||||
|
||||
שכ"ג מ 7/2 !! תגובה 713196 |
|
||||
|
||||
>> ומה הביקורת שלך בה? אתה אומר שם שלא היה צריך לפתוח את המספרות, אבל את מערכת החינוך היה צריך לפתוח מזמן. ככה היינו בולמים את התפרצות הגל השני (שכידוע החל במערכת החינוך). . . נו באמת. אני לא מבין. את תגובה 717779 כתבתי בעברית. כתבתי שם: "גני ילדים ובתי ספר יסודיים- כן, עם שני סימני קריאה, ומזמן. לפני כל דבר אחר. חט"ב - כבר עכשיו, יחד עם ההקלות הראשונות בסגר. פעוטונים ותיכונים- רק בשלב מאוחר יותר, יחד עם חזרה מלאה לשגרה." הסבר: גני ילדים ובתי ספר יסודיים מהווים לדעתי סיכון נמוך מצד אחד, ומשחררים את ההורים ללכת לעבודה מצד שני. בתי ספר תיכוניים מהווים סיכון גבוה (מה שהתברר כנכון), ואם לא פותחים אותם עדיין ההורים יכולים ללכת לעבודה. צריך לחכות עם הפתיחה שלהם עד שמתברר שגם בלי סגר מלא התפשטות המגפה נמצאת תחת בקרה. הממשלה בחרה לא לשחרר את ההורים לעבודה, על ידי שעיכבה את פתיחת הגנים והיסודיים. החלטה זו החמירה את המשבר הכלכלי. מאידך הממשלה החליטה לפתוח את התיכונים יחד עם היסודיים (מה שהתברר כהחלטה הרת אסון). השילוב של שתיהן גרם לכך שמחירו הכלכלי של הסגר היה כבד, ושכל ההישגים שלו בבלימת המגפה נמחקו. בפברואר ומרץ לא עסקתי כלל בביקורת על צעדי הממשלה. באותו זמן עניינה אותי ההתפתחות הגלובלית של המחלה והשפעתה על שווקי העולם. ביקרתי בזמן אמת את איטליה על כך שלא עשתה סגר על מילאנו וסביבתה מוקדם יותר. צעד בודד זה היה יכול לשנות את כל מבנה ההתפרצות של המגפה בעולם. העבודה שלי דרשה ממני עבודה מאוד אינטנסיבית מסביב לשעון ולא הקדשתי תשומת לב רבה למתרחש בארצנו, לאור תנאי הפתיחה המצויינים שלנו ומתוך הנחה נאיבית שהממשלה יודעת מה היא עושה לאור ההחלטה המוקדמת המצוינת לסגור את השמים. כזכור לך אני לא עוקב אחרי ערוצי החדשות המקומיים. בכל זאת הייתי מוטרד מהכמות הנמוכה של בדיקות יזומות אצלנו, וקראתי ללמוד מקוריאה. הפעם הראשונה שהתייחסתי בהרחבה לאסטרטגיה של ההתמודדות עם המגפה בארץ היתה ב 19/4 תגובה 717364 ושם קראתי לפתוח את הגנים ובתי הספר היסודיים, ולשמור יותר על האוכלוסיה בסיכון (ואף הצעתי דרכים לכך), משום ש"לא ניתן יהיה להמשיך בסגר עד שהחיסון יהיה זמין בלי פגיעה מסיבית, שלא לומר אנושה, במשק." משם והלאה קראתי לפתוח את הגנים והיסודיים (ולא את הפעוטונים והתיכונים), משום שהסגר ארוך מדי ומחירו (הכלכלי, ובסופו של דבר גם בחיי אדם) יהיה גבוה. בפועל משכו את הסגר הכללי עד הקצה ואז פתחו את כל המשק בלי בקרה. נושא שני של הביקורת שלי היה על האכיפה. קראתי להחמיר את האכיפה, כולל צעדים דרקוניים נגד מי שמסכן את הציבור. הצעתי להכניס את הרב קנייבסקי (שקרא להמשיך את התפילות בציבור ואת הלימודים בישיבות כרגיל בזמן הסגר) למעצר כדי להעביר את המסר. תמכתי בדיעבד בחום בהחלטה על הסגר המלא בליל הסדר. אכן טעיתי טעות מרה כשחשבתי שהקיץ יביא להורדה מספקת של מקדם ההדבקה עד כדי שהמגפה תהיה מאחורינו ללא צורך בצעדים נוספים, אבל חזרתי בי כשהתבררה הטעות. את כל אלו עשיתי כמשקיף מזדמן, ולא כמי שעוסק בכך במשרה מלאה. למי שזה עיסוקם היה את דו"ח מרכז המידע והידע הלאומי למערכה בקורונה מ 20.6 שחזה בדייקנות את התפרצות הגל השני. שים לב מה הם כותבים "מה צפוי שיקרה בשבועות הקרובים אם לא ינקטו צעדים? ההבדל המרכזי בין הגל הנוכחי לבין הגל הראשון, הוא שבראשון הוטלו הגבלות הולכות ומחמירות החל מאמצע חודש מרץ אשר בסופו של דבר הובילו לירידה במספר הנדבקים. כעת, מאז אמצע אפריל, ההקלות ההולכות ומתרחבות, עלולות לא רק להוביל להמשך העלייה אלא אף להאצתה. להערכתנו, בהנחה שלא ינקטו פעולות כלשהן, ועל בסיס ההנחות המחקריות (הלא מחמירות) המנויות מטה, הרי שבתוך כחודש מספר הנפטרים הכולל יגיע למאות רבות." ומה הם ממליצים: "המלצות למדיניות לאור זאת, אנו ממליצים, בראש ובראשונה: o לשקול מחדש את ההקלות עליהן הוחלט בימים האחרונים, הן מבחינת השלכותיהן על התחלואה והן מבחינת המסר שהן משדרות לציבור. o להרחיב משמעותית את ההסברה ברמה הלאומית והמקומית (שכן עולה החשש שחומרת המצב אינה ברורה דיה לציבור), לרבות מיקוד מאמצי הסברה ייעודיים למגזרים השונים. בראייתנו, דוגמא אישית בקרב מנהיגים ובכירים במשק ובכלל המערכת הציבורית (עטיית מסיכות, ריחוק) תהווה גורם משמעותי בתמיכה במאמצי ההסברה. o להרחיב את האכיפה, ואת סמכויות האכיפה של הרשויות המקומיות במרחב הציבורי. o לגבש מנגנון יעיל לאכיפת הבידוד, לאור פער מסתמן בהיבט זה. o לממש באופן מואץ את מנגנוני קטיעת שרשראות ההדבקה שהוקמו לאחרונה, ולהרחיב במהירות את כוח האדם המוקצה לחקירות האפידמיולוגיות, כך שיוכל לעמוד בקצבי התחלואה הגדלים במהירות. o לממש מנגנון יעיל לפינוי מבודדים וחולים למלוניות. להבנתנו, ללא ביצוע מהיר והחלטי של צעדים אלה, אשר עלותם המשקית מצומצמות באופן יחסי, מדינת ישראל עלולה בעוד כחודש להידרש להחלטות כלכליות וחברתיות כואבות בהרבה." |
|
||||
|
||||
את התגובה ההיא כתבת כשבועיים אחרי שיא המגיפה כשהחלו לפתוח את המשק. אכן כתבת שגני ילדים ובתי ספר יסודיים היה צריך לפתוח מזמן, מיד אחרי פסח (כאן לא דיברת על מה שצריך לעשות בתאריך כתיבת התגובה, אלא על משהו שהיה לדבריך צריך לעשות עוד כשהתחלואה הייתה בעלייה). אבל לא שמענו ממך שאולי אסור לפתוח באותו תאריך שנכתבה תגובתך גם בתי ספר אחרים, ובכלל לא השמעת שום ביקורת על צעדי הממשלה בפתיחת המשק ואזהרות שהדבר הזה יכול להוביל להתפרצות חדשה, לא באותו תאריך שכתבת תגובה זו ולא בשבועות מאז עד שהחלה העליה החדשה בתחלואה. גם לא שמענו ממך שום ביקורת על דברי לנצט שנאמרו שבועיים אחר כך, שלפיהם הכל נגמר ולא צריך להיזהר משום דבר, למרות שברור שקראת את דבריו. היום אתה מבקר את הממשלה על כך שבגלל צעדים לא נכונים שנקטה החל הגל השני. אזהרות בתקופה הרלוונטית לא שמענו, ולכן קראתי לכך חכמה שבדיעבד. אתה משיב בתגובות ארוכות אבל לא משיב לטענה שלי. |
|
||||
|
||||
שאלה קטנה: אני מבין את רוב התמיהות שלך. אני רק לא מבין מה קשורה עמדתו של לנצט לכאן. מדובר על דעתו של מומחה אחד. לעצם העניין באותו הזמן בערך הנהגת הקורונה הממשלה התעלמה מקבוצות המומחים שהיא עצמה מינתה והן פנו ישירות ציבור מעל לראשה של הנהגת הקורונה. |
|
||||
|
||||
המדד הוא לא "מה אריק מהאייל הקורא אמר שצריך לעשות" (עם כל הכבוד לאריק), אלא מה מדינות אחרות עשו אחרי הגל הראשון. אם זה יעלה למחלוקת אנסה למצוא נתונים, אבל אני בטוח שמדינות אחרות *לא פתחו* את מערכת החינוך שלהן בבת אחת. מדינות אחרות *שיפרו* את היכולת שלהן לאתר נדבקים במהירות. מדינות אחרות *הגבירו* את כמות הבדיקות שהן מסוגלות לעשות. מדינות אחרות קבעו *שבועות מראש* מה יהיה סדר פתיחת המשק עם קריטריונים ברורים שהיא אשכרה בדקה ועמדה בהם. הניסיון להאשים את הציבור בברוך הזה גובל באי-מוסריות של ממש. הציבור ישב בליל הסדר לבד בבית, בזמן שראש הממשלה והנשיא אירחו את בני המשפחה שלהם. הציבור הפסיק לקיים אירועים בזמן ששר הבריאות אירגן מסיבת יום הולדת לאישתו בנוכחות עשרות אנשים. בכל מדינה מתוקנת (שים לב שלא כתבתי "בכל מדינה מתוקנת אחרת"), נציג ציבור שנוהג כך היה מפוטר או מתפטר. והיו מקרים. אבל בישראל לא רק שהם נשארים בתפקידם, אלא יש להם את העוז לבקר התנהלות של הציבור. כשהוחלט לסגור מסעדות, מסעדנים ששיתפו פעולה עם ההנחיות מכרו את המלאים שהיו להם המכירי הפסד, רק כדי להבין כמה שעות (שעות!) לאחר מכן שהם יצאו פראיירים כי הממשלה נבהלה והחליטה לפתוח את המסעדות מחשש ל"חרם". מה אדם רציונלי אמור להבין מזה? שההנחיות לא באמת חשובות אם יש לך מספיק כח להתעלם מהן. נכון, יש הבדלים תרבותיים בין מדינות וישראל היא לא דרום קוראיה או יפן. אבל חלק מתפקיד ממשלה הוא לגרום לאזרחים לשתף פעולה עם ההנחיות שלה, לא להנחית הנחיות חדשות מדי פעם ולצפות שהציבור יעמוד בהן. מה שהממשלה הזאת עשתה הוא בדיוק ההפך - הדגימה לציבור שהיא עצמה מזלזלת בהנחיות ושרק פראיירים משתפים פעולה. עם התנהלות כזאת, אין לה (או לך) שום זכות לבוא בתלונות לציבור. |
|
||||
|
||||
זאת ועוד - מדינות אחרות תחקרו את הגל הראשון, על כשליו ובעיותיו, הפיקו לקחים ולמדו איך להשתפר לקראת הגל שני (וגם בין הגלים). פה לא תחקרו ולא הסיקו כלום - והרי למה לתחקר שלטון שאינו טועה לעולם? |
|
||||
|
||||
מה עשו מדינות אחרות מצחיק. הכתבה הזו מ 26/3, שלשה ימים אחרי התגובה שלי. ושם אנחנו מוצאים את "המתווה המסתמן, לפיו בדיוק בעוד שבוע (3.5) יחזרו בהדרגה ללימודים תלמידי כיתות א' עד ג', בקבוצות של כ-15 תלמידים. כיתות ד' עד ט' יישארו בשלב זה בבית, ותלמידי כיתות י' עד י"ב ילמדו לבגרויות מרחוק או בקבוצות קטנות." איך זה נגמר בסוף, כולם יודעים. |
|
||||
|
||||
אכן, מדינות אחרות לא פתחו את מערכת החינוך בבת אחת. באיטליה למשל לא פתחו כלל את מערכת החינוך ל-2019/20 ויתחילו רק בשנת הלימודיםן הקרובה. בגרמניה פתחו בטפטוף איטי להפליא - תחילה קבוצות תלמידים ספציפיות שעומדות בפני בחינות חשובות ולמדו במשמרות, אחר כך כיתות שעומדות בפני סיום שלב (סיום בי"ס יסודי וכו') ורק בסוף את כל המערכת, כשברוב גרמניה הפתיחה היתה בקבוצות קטנות ומפוזרות - ברמה שכל תלמיד קיבל שבוע לימודים אחד, של שלוש שעות ביום, לפני סוף השנה, רק כדי 'לסמן' את סוף השנה (בשתיים-שלוש מדינות פדרליות שהתחלואה בהן היתה נמוכה מאוד מאוד התקיימו לימודים יותר מסודרים, כפוף למגבלות שונות ומשונות). רק עכשיו - עם תחילת שנת הלימודים החדשה - מתחילים פתיחה מלאה. אני לא יודע איך זה במדינות אחרות באירופה אבל אני מאמין שבכולן זה היה יותר בזהירות מאשר בישראל. הערה שנייה: אם מחפשים גורם בודד, הגורם המובהק ביותר להאצת גל השני לא היה פתיחת התיכונים אלא אישור האירועים באולמות. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני כתבתי: אני לא מבין. את תגובה 717779 כתבתי בעברית. כתבתי שם: "גני ילדים ובתי ספר יסודיים- כן, עם שני סימני קריאה, ומזמן. לפני כל דבר אחר. חט"ב - כבר עכשיו, יחד עם ההקלות הראשונות בסגר. פעוטונים ותיכונים- רק בשלב מאוחר יותר, יחד עם חזרה מלאה לשגרה." ואתה ענית : אבל לא שמענו ממך שאולי אסור לפתוח באותו תאריך שנכתבה תגובתך גם בתי ספר אחרים אז אני אדגיש שוב: "פעוטונים ותיכונים- רק בשלב מאוחר יותר, יחד עם חזרה מלאה לשגרה." אתה בכלל קורא מה שאני כותב? |
|
||||
|
||||
אכן בקריאתי כנראה דילגתי על הפסקה שהדגשת, ואני מתנצל על כך. הטענה שלך, אם כך, היא שהבעיה שגרמה להתפרצות הגל השני הייתה פתיחת הפעוטונים והתיכונים. איני זוכר מתי בדיוק פתחו אותם, אבל כשפתחו אותם, לא נשמעה ממך אף מילת ביקורת. אם הזמן שבו נפתחו התיכונים לא נכנס למסגרת ה''מאוחר יותר'' שהגדרת, הייתי מצפה ממך לזעוק ולהתריע. אבל לא שמענו אז שום זעקה כזאת. את הזעקות אנו שומעים רק היום, וזו חכמה שבדיעבד. |
|
||||
|
||||
נכון, זו חכמה בדיעבד. ומה בכך? אם הייתי מתריע בזמן אמת האם הממשלה היתה חוזרת בה? הרי לא יכולתי להתריע מראש, מול תכנית מסודרת. התכנית התאימה לכוונות שלי- לפתוח את התיכונים והפעוטונים מאוחר יותר. ההחלטות השתנו מהיום למחר והופס התיכונים נפתחו. היסודיים חזרו ב 3 במאי, הקניונים ב 7 במאי, והתיכונים ב 19 במאי, ללא קפסולות וללא אמצעי זהירות. ב 26 למאי קרתה ההתפרצות בגימנסיה הרצליה. איש צוות הגיע לעבודה מספר ימים עם סימפטומים. אני הייתי זורק אותו לכלא להרבה זמן ועושה מזה רעש כדי לייצר הרתעה. |
|
||||
|
||||
" איש צוות הגיע לעבודה מספר ימים עם סימפטומים" - יש לך במקרה מקור לכך? אני כתבתי כמה פעמים שחשוב מאוד לחקור את ההתפרצות הזאת ולראות אם המקורי היה תלמיד או איש צוות, ולא ידעתי שהתבצעה חקירה ואלו מסקנותיה. אשמח להשכיל. |
|
||||
|
||||
יש "לפי מסמך של מרכז הידע והמידע למאבק בקורונה, השיעורים בגימנסיה העברית התבצעו בצפיפות רבה (35 תלמידים בכיתה), וידוע על לפחות מקרה אחד של איש צוות שהגיע לבית הספר עם סימפטומים במשך כמה ימים." והלכתי את המייל הנוסף, הנה הדו"ח עצמו |
|
||||
|
||||
אם אתה מסכים שמדובר בחכמה בדיעבד, אז איני מבין לשם מה טרחנו בחילופי התגובות הקודמות. זו הייתה טענתי. אני איני מאמין בחשיבות של ניהול כזה או ניהול אחר, צבא או גוף אזרחי, פרוייקטור שחרחר או פרוייקטור ג'ינג'י. אני (במיוחד היום עם הניסיון שנצבר) מאמין רק בדבר אחד והוא צעדים נמרצים וקשים בכל רגע שרואים שהניף מרים ראש, כפי שספרתי מספר פעמים על תגובת ממשלת דרום קוריאה בגלל גילוי של 150 חולים בעיר בת 7 מליון נפש, וכפי שנוהגים בסין. בזמן שבו התפרסם הראיון הראשון עם לנצט היינו כולנו, ואני מודה שזה כולל גם אותי, מאד רגועים. אני, אמנם כתבתי שאני חושב שהוא מדבר שטויות, כי בניגוד לו הייתי בטוח שההקלות יביאו בשלב מסוים לגידול בתחלואה, אך לא שיערתי ברע שבחלומותיי שההתפרצות תהיה בעצמה כזאת שתביא לתחלואה כפולה (בינתיים) מזו שהייתה בגל הראשון. לכן, כשהחל מספר החולים לעלות (ולנצט סיפר לנו שמדובר בחפירה בקרחון, ולא במשהו שבאמת קורה), לא זעקתי, כפי שבדיעבד אני יודע שצריך היה, שיש להחמיר מאד בהגבלות על האוכלוסייה ולאכוף את ההתנהגות הנכונה בעצמה רבה. אבל בניגוד לך איני בא בטענות קשות לממשלה על המחדל הזה. איש לא צפה זאת אז, ואי אפשר לבוא בטענות על סמך חכמה בדיעבד. |
|
||||
|
||||
מה שהכי חמור בעיני הוא לא השאלה אם ההחלטות היו נכונות, אלא צורת ניהול המשבר והחשש הקרוב לוודאי שחלק גדול מההחלטות לא היו אופטימליות *גם בעיני המחליטים* אבל הם נכנעו ללחץ של קבוצות שונות. כלומר, הבעיה העיקרית היא תהליך קבלת ההחלטות, יותר מאשר ההחלטות עצמן, אם כי ברור שתהליך חולה משפיע גם על טיב התוצאה. "מחיר הפוליטיקה", אותו ג'וקר בו מנופפים כדי להכשיר כל שרץ שלטוני, הגיע למקום בו הוא מגמד אפילו את מניות טסלה, בגלל המצב הפוליטי הפתולוגי. בימים בהם ראש הממשלה תלוי בצורה מוחלטת באותו בלוק ששומר עליו לא רק לשם המשך שלטונו אלא בעיקר כדי לספק לו כרטיס יציאה מבית הסוהר הוא פגיע וסחיט, וחייב לחשוב בראש ובראשונה על הפופולאריות הציבורית שלו אצל מצביעיו, ולא פחות מזה אצל מצביעי הבלוק שלו כולו. כך, למשל, מוזמזה במשך חודשים רבים ההחלטה להעביר למשרד הביטחון חלק משמעותי מהטיפול במשבר לא מסיבות ענייניות אלא בגלל שאלות של כוח ותהילה (חכמה בדיעבד? לאו דווקא תגובה 715574), וכך גם הטיפול באוכלוסיות "בעייתיות", כאשר ברור שאם אינך יכול להטיל סגר על ריכוזי חרדים נפגעת גם היכולת שלך לעשות זאת במוקדי התפרצות אחרים, לפחות כל עוד האפרטהייד השלטוני מוגבל לשטחי יו"ש. יש דוגמאות רבות אחרות בהן קיים לפחות חשש סביר שזה המצב - הייתי מציין את הסתרת הסכם השלום עם האמירויות משרי הבטחון והחוץ אבל אחרי פרשת הצוללות אני לא בטוח למה לייחס אותה; אולי לסתם הנאה קטנה מנעיצת עוד אצבע בעין של גנץ, ואולי לתקווה שזה יגרום ל"כחול לבן" לפרק את הקואליציה ולגרום לבחירות חדשות כשנהתניהו לא רק קוצר את תהילת השלום אלא גם גורם ל"כחול לבן" לשאת באשמת הבחירות, מה שהיה מוחק סופית אפילו את מעט המנדטים שעוד יש להם. ו *זה* המחיר שהציבור המטומטם1 משלם על כך שהוא מאפשר לנאשם שעומד לדין בעברות כבדות להמשיך ולנהל את המדינה. אין לי אלא לחזור על המנטרה Democracy us a device that ensures we shall be governed no better than we deserve או, בתרגומו של ירדן, "הדמוקרטיה מבטיחה שלא נקבל ממשלה טובה יותר מכפי שמגיע לנו". _______________ 1- זה לא אני, זה שלום חנוך |
|
||||
|
||||
הסיבה שביבי מבצע שוב ושוב את אותן ״שגיאות״ כביכול זה לא כי הוא טועה או כי הוא קטנוני וסתם נהנה מנעיצת עוד אצבע בעין של גנץ. זו מדיניות. המהלכים של נתניהו וההשתנה שלו מהמקפצה הם מהלכים מחושבים ובהתיעצות עם עורכי הדין פחי הזבל שיש לו. הוא בכוונה ממשיך לבצע פעולות שהן חמורות לא פחות (או אפילו יותר) מהדברים שהוא מואשם בהם בתיקיו הפליליים כחלק מתהליך בישול הצפרדע. כל פעולותיו הן על מנת לצייר את התיקים כעוסקים בזוטות. היינו מצפים מאדם עם תיק פלילי הקשור לקבלת מתנות ממליונרים שינקוט זהירות יתרה בנושא, אבל לא! ביבי מבקש שוב ושוב *באופן רשמי* מועדות שיאשרו לו לקבל מתנות ממליונרים למימון משפטו. היינו מצפים ממישהו שמואשם ברמז שהוא בגד במדינה ופעל מאחורי גבה של מערכת הביטחון שיתחיל לנקוט ביתר זהירות ויתחיל לשתף את המערכת בכל פרט. אבל לעשות זאת זה כמו להודות שהוא פעל לא נכון בעניין הצוללות. הדרך שתבטיח לו הגנה היא להמשיך לפעול כך באופן מוצהר ועקבי ולקבע זאת כעבודה - ראש ממשלה, כעניין שבשיגרה, יכול לעשות מה שהוא רוצה מאחורי גבה של מערכת הביטחון ושר הביטחון. המטרה של כל הפעולות הללו בשיגרה היא כדי לבסס נורמות חדשות. עד שהנאשם יגיע לבית המשפט, הוא דואג שההתנהגויות בהן הוא מואשם הן פשוט ההתנהלות הנורמטיבית של ניהול מדינת ישראל על ידי ראש ממשלה נבחר. אז מה השופטים הנודניקים האלה מתערבים? מה הערך של כל תיק השמפניות והסיגרים כאשר יש דיונים רשמיים אם לאשר לנתניהו מתנות ממליונרים במאות אלפי דולרים? מה יהיה הערך של תיק המתנות אחרי שהוא יצליח להקים את הועדה (זה עניין של זמן של שהעציצים של כחול לבן יתנו לו לעשות את זה בטיעון ״רק לא בחירות״) שתאשר לו כל מה שהוא רוצה? |
|
||||
|
||||
עברת מדיון ממוקד בשאלת האשמה בפריצת הגל השני של הקורונה לכל מיני עניינים שמקהלת האופוזיציה עוסקת בהם. אגיב רק על משהו שצרם את עיני במיוחד: "זה המחיר שהציבור המטומטם משלם על כך שהוא מאפשר לנאשם שעומד לדין בעברות כבדות להמשיך ולנהל את המדינה". בראיה שלי אותן "עבירות כבדות" "כשלג ילבינו" כמאמר הנביא, כשמשווים אותן למה שאנו רואים מתנהל בתוך הפרקליטות, במידה מסוימת עם גב של שופטי בית המשפט העליון. ואם הציבור רואה זאת כמוני אז הוא דווקא חכם. |
|
||||
|
||||
שים לב שאתה מאשים ומטיל את האחריות למחדלי הגל השני על לנצט וחבריו שלחשו בפרטיות על אוזנו של נתניהו והרגיעו אותו שאין גל שני. מצד שני, אתה מנקה מאחריות (לפחות בשורה המסכמת) את נתניהו שהטה אוזן למלחשים במקום לשלוח אותם לשכנע את הגורמים המקצועיים. שיטת הניהול הפלצנית של נתניהו, המסכסך בין משרתיו ומכריע בעניינים בהם אין לו שום מושג היא האחראית למדיניות הישראלית הכושלת מראשית ועד אחרית בתקופת הקורונה. כל המדיניות של נתניהו היתה זרועה הצהרות ריקות וצעדים שגויים. הצהרה ריקה זה לסגור את השמיים ובמקביל לאפשר לליצמן וגפני לארגן רכבת אוירית של חולי קורונה מארה''ב לישראל שרובם אפילו אינם אזרחי המדינה. צעדים שגויים זה לכלוא בבתיהם מיליוני אזרחים נקיים ולהכות מכת סנוקרת את המשק הישראלי, רק כדי שהאזרחים החרדים לא ירגישו מופלים וישלחו את נתניהולספסל הנאשמים. אני מניח שלנצט קשור לכל הסיפור הזה בעיקר בגלל חטאי נעוריו המשוערים בשוה''צ. |
|
||||
|
||||
אין זה נכון שאני מאשים ומטיל את האחריות למחדלי הגל השני על לנצט וחבריו. טענתי בפתיל זה היא שלכולם קשה לצפות מה מכין לנו הנגיף המרגיז הזה, ולכן למרות שהממשלה אכן נכשלה באי עריפת ראשו של הנגיף מיד בתחילת הגל השני1, אין זה הוגן לצאת היום להפגנות בעניין זה. אילו הפגנות כאלה שמצביעות על מחדלי הממשלה, היו נערכות אז, בזמן שהגל הראשון דעך וכאשר התחיל הגל השני להתעורר (בקטן), ואחר כך כולנו היינו עדים למה שקורה, אז בפרוש הייתי אומר שהייתה להן הצדקה. אבל חכמה בדיעבד אינה מצדיקה צווחות. את חלקם של לנצט וחבריו הסברתי באריכות בתגובה 721359 . התרומה השלילית שלהם היא לא איזה לחש מסתורי על אזנו של ראש הממשלה, כפי שאתה מתאר את דעתי, אלא הגברת השאננות בציבור באמצעות דברי ההבל שלהם. כששומעים פרופסור ממכון ויצמן אומר בכזה בטחון עצמי דבר מסוים, קשה להאשים את האזרח "הקטן" בכך שהוא משתכנע. וההשתכנעות בשטות הזאת במלחמה הזאת היא כמו הזרמת בנזין לשריפה. לעניין המשפט האחרון בתגובתך שמתייחס לידע אישי שלי, שהובא כאן כאנקדוטה הומוריסטית, ההנחה שלך מאפיינת שוב את ניסיונך להיכנס לתוך מוחי, ניסיונות שנכשלים שוב ושוב. אם אזכיר את החתול תיעלב. אז לא אזכיר אותו הפעם. 1 את החברה האלה צריך להרוג כשהם עוד קטנים. |
|
||||
|
||||
א. "אין זה נכון שאני מאשים ומטיל את האחריות למחדלי הגל השני על לנצט וחבריו" - בודאי שאתה מאשים. אתה סתם מסתתר מאחורי דקדוקי עניות. לא כתבתי שאתה טוען שלנצט הוא האשם היחיד או האחראי המיניסטריאלי. אם הוא לא אשם, מה אתה נטפל לאיש מדע שטעה בהבנת העובדות שהגיעו לידיו ועשה עצמו לצחוק בעיני הקולגות? ב. "טענתי בפתיל זה היא שלכולם קשה לצפות מה מכין לנו הנגיף המרגיז הזה" - לא נכון ולא קשור. עובדה שקואומו, מושל ניו יורק, לא איש מדע דגול, תאר יפה מאד את סכנות הגל השני (עוד בתקופה שאתה חשבת שהגל השני הוא המצאה של שמאלנים חמוצים). לא קשור, מפני שגם אריק וגם אני, שחשבנו באותה תקופה שלא יהיה גל שני לפני החורף, הבחנו מיד כאשר לנצט ובן ישראל פרסמו את מאמרם, שהפרשנות שלהם לעובדות אינה עולה בקנה אחד עם עובדות אחרות. אני במקרה זוכר מדוע חשבתי כך. מעקב ברזולוציה יומית אחרי מספר החולים הקשים, הראה שבמשך כל תקופת הרגיעה שבין הגלים היה רצף של חולים קשים חדשים. הדרך היחידה ליישב זאת עם אי קיומו של גל שני, היא להניח שכל המקרים הללו היו מקרים ישנים שהסתבכו ולכך לא ראיתי שום ראיה. הנה כי כן,לא היה צורך להיות חזאי מגפות מדופלם על מנת להבחין שהפרופ' הנכבד עושה עצמו לצחוק. אולי משום כך, שנינו לא כל כך כועסים עליו או מיחסים לו אחריות לא לו. אני לפחות, כמו לדעתי, רוב העולם, לא כולל אותך, מכירים בתקפות טענתו הבסיסית, שמספר הנשאים הוא גם פונקציה של מספר הבדיקות. ג, "ולכן למרות שהממשלה אכן נכשלה באי עריפת ראשו של הנגיף מיד בתחילת הגל השני" - לא כל כך בטוח. כמעט בכל המדינות יש גל שני. ישנן כאלו שהצליחו יותר בבלימתו, ישנן כאלו שפחות, וישנן כאלו שטורחות לא לבדוק ולכן יכולות להכחיש את קיומו. לאור מה שקורה עכשיו, כאשר יודעים יותר, מה צריך לעשות ובכל זאת לא מצליחים לעשות זאת, אני לא בטוח שהממשלה בכלל יכלה לעשות משהו, ועד כמה הצעדים היו אפקטיביים. נניח שלא היו פותחים את בתי הספר. אתה חושב שההורים יכלו להמשיך לכלוא את הילדים בבתים? ד. "אין זה הוגן לצאת היום להפגנות בעניין זה. אילו הפגנות כאלה שמצביעות על מחדלי הממשלה, היו נערכות אז, בזמן שהגל הראשון דעך וכאשר התחיל הגל השני להתעורר (בקטן), ואחר כך כולנו היינו עדים למה שקורה, אז בפרוש הייתי אומר שהייתה להן הצדקה. אבל חכמה בדיעבד אינה מצדיקה צווחות" - זו אמירה מופרכת שאופיינית לתומכיו של שלטון הימין שדגלו הוא "כל ממזר מלך". 90% מן הדמוקרטיה בנויים על כך שאזרחים בחכמה שלאחר מעשה, מחליטים אם השלטון הקיים הוכיח עצמו או כשל וראוי להחליפו. נראה ששכחת לרגע את אחד מן המסרים של חבורת המנהיג - "שלטון לא מחליפים בהפגנות". רוב האזרחים הפשוטים מכירים בכך שהם נעדרי הכישורים והיכולות הנדרשות להנהגה ובכל זאת לוקחים לעצמם את הזכות לשפוט בחכמה שלאחר מעשה את השלטון. רק שלטון הממלא את מושבי הכנסת והממשלה באנשים נחותים ובמלחכי פנכה שזו אמנותם, יכול להעלות על הדעת שחכמת ההמון וחכמת השלטון הם אותו הדבר. ה. "התרומה השלילית שלהם (לנצט) היא לא איזה לחש מסתורי על אזנו של ראש הממשלה, כפי שאתה מתאר את דעתי, אלא הגברת השאננות בציבור באמצעות דברי ההבל שלהם" - קודם כל לא תארתי את דעתך אלא את דעתי. עד כמה הדברים משפיעים על ההמון או על נתניהו, זה בהחלט עניין לדיון. בכל מקרה אציין שוב, שהיו הדיוטות שקראו את דברי הפרופ' במקור והעזו להביע דעתם שהפרופ' טועה והיו כאלו שהסתפקו בבשורה ע"פ לנצט בתקשורת הפופולארית,שם הדברים צריכים להתחרות בבשורות האחרונות מהישרדות ומתחרות שף המטבח. ו. "לעניין המשפט האחרון בתגובתך שמתייחס לידע אישי שלי, שהובא כאן כאנקדוטה הומוריסטית, ההנחה שלך מאפיינת שוב את ניסיונך להיכנס לתוך מוחי, ניסיונות שנכשלים שוב ושוב. אם אזכיר את החתול תיעלב. אז לא אזכיר אותו הפעם" - בעניין הניסיון להיכנס לתוך המוח: כל דו שיח אינטלגנטי, מכיל מרכיב של ניסיון לקרוא את מוחו של בן שיחך. אולי מוטב שדוקא אתה תשקיע בכך קצת יותר. לעניין עלבונות החתול, הרשה לי להעמיד דברים על דיוקם. לא נעלבתי. הבנתי, אחרי שכתבת זאת, שאתה רואה בכך הומורסקה מחודדת מן הזן הקישוני. אני ראיתי בכך סתם גסות רוח המעידה על ילדות שנייה. מי צודק? בעניין זה מוטב שתשאל אחרים. אתה רשאי להמשיך בעלבונות אלו או לחדול מהם לפי טעמך ושיקולך. |
|
||||
|
||||
וכל זה בלי שאמרנו מלה אחת על התקציב (יותר נכון- היעדרו) בזמן חירום, כשהוא נדרש במיוחד. בלי שאמרנו מלה על היערכות מערכת החינוך לפתיחת שנה"ל (יותר נכון- היעדרה) בלי שאמרנו מלה על זה שפרויקטור קורונה מונה רק בשלהי יולי, כשהגרף של דב כבר איים לצאת מהמעטפת (אחרי ששניים אחרים ויתרו על התפקיד), ועדיין לא ברורות סמכויותיו1. ________________ 1 ותהיה קטנה- למה באחת בלילה? אי אפשר להחליט על משהו פעם אחת בצהריים? |
|
||||
|
||||
גם מינוי הפרויקטור לתושבי הצפון נדחה שוב ושוב (למה מי מת, חוץ מכמה אלפים?) מה שמעלה את השאלה התיאולוגית אם אלוהים יכול לברוא פרויקטור שיהיה מקובל גם על שרה וגם על גלי. |
|
||||
|
||||
עוד משהו קטן על שותף של הפרוייקטור. |
|
||||
|
||||
דומני ששיקול הדעת של צ'ייני הוכח היטב עוד בפרשת המרמרה. |
|
||||
|
||||
אענה רק על הסעיף האחרון, כי התעייפתי, אך לא נוח לי שאתה ממשיך לא להבין את עניין החתול. זה בפרוש לא "הומורסקה מחודדת מן הזן הקישוני". קישון בכלל לא חווה ילדות בארץ והוא רחוק מהאמירה הזאת כרחוק מזרח ממערב. אחזור ואסביר שוב ואקווה שהפעם תבין. כשאתה מטיח בי דברים חסרי שחר ללא כל הוכחה, כשאני מזכיר את החתול אני מתכוון שדברים חסרי שחר גם אני יכול להטיח בך. כמו שילד בריב עם חברו אומר לו: אתה כך וכך. והחבר משיב: אתה בעצמך כך וכך. אין לכך כל תוחלת. |
|
||||
|
||||
לא בפעם הראשונה, הריני להבטיחך שהבנתי את הרעיון בעצמי, עוד לפני הסבריך המרובים. ועדיין חשבתי שמדובר בגסות רוח סרת טעם. אתה כמובן אינך מחוייב בכללי הטעם והריח שלי וכבר הצעתי שתשאל מישהו אחר בעניין זה (למשל בני ביתך). אם איש אינו מתנדב להביע דעתו, מן הסתם אנו משעממים את הציבור ומוטב שנחדול כאן. |
|
||||
|
||||
אפשר להשתמש אולי בגרסה האמריקאית שמתעסקת פחות עם קקי ופיפי: I'm rubber you're glue, your words bounce off me and stick to you. |
|
||||
|
||||
א. ובאופן כללי: אין קבוצה של מומחים שמתוקף תפקידה צריכה לנסות להבין את המצב, לייעץ לשלטונות וגם לספק את המידע לציבור. נוצרו כמה קבוצות של מומחים, אבל השלטונות לא התחשבו יותר מדי בדעותיהם. מכיוון שיש כמה צוותים שונים ואף אחד מהם אינו בעל השפעה, אין התייחסות רצינית ותהודה ציבורית לדעותיהם. לכן יש גם תהודה רחבה יותר לדעות שאינן בקונצנזוס, כגון אלו של לנצט ושל בן ישראל. זה לגיטימי להשמיע דרכי ניתוח שונות על התקדמות המשבר, אבל חשוב להבין מה מעמדן של דרכי הניתוח הללו בעיני עיקר המומחים. ובארץ אין גוף מומחים שדעותיו מוכרות על הציבור. זה לא מקרה: אם היה כזה, זה היה מוקד כוח שיכול לקדם עמדה שונה מזו של נתניהו ולכן להיות מוקד כוח עצמאי. וזה לא מצב בריא, אליבא דנתניהו. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני חולק עליך בשאלה אם העברות ילבינו כשלג, אבל זה לא העניין כרגע. אין ויכוח על כך שראש הממשלה מואשם בעברות כבדות משקל, ואין לי ספק שחלק גדול מהתנהלותו מושפע מכך. זאת הנקודה שהעליתי. (אם מישהו זקוק להבהרה, אני רחוק מלחשוב שהפרקליטות ומערכת המשפט בכללה הן גופים חפים מבעיות, ראה לדוגמא תגובה 670238 . בשאלת המשקל היחסי של הבעיות האלה למול ראש ממשלה מכהן בזמן שהוא עומד למשפט שעלול להסתיים בבית סוהר מפריד בינינו קניון ואליס מארינריס). |
|
||||
|
||||
מה הבעיה שלך עם חכמה בדיעבד, ומה ההבדל אם הייתי אומר בזמן אמת? היו דברים שאמרתי בזמן אמת, וגם הם לא עזרו. הרי אני לא פרויקטור הקורונה, והבנתי שגם פרויקטור הקורונה נתקל בקירות פוליטיים ולא מצליח לעשות דברים שהוא רוצה. הטענה שלי היא שהממשלות האחרונות לא מתפקדות בכל התחומים האזרחיים, ושמשבר הקורונה חשף את זה לעין כל. אתה לא מאמין בחשיבות של ניהול כזה או אחר, אבל אתה רוצה צעדים תקיפים כמו בקוריאה. מי יעשה אותם? בהגדרה מי שמנהל את המשבר. מישהו פאקינג צריך לנהל את המשבר, וכדי לנהל את המשבר הוא צריך סמכויות ויכולות. >> איש לא צפה זאת אז, ואי אפשר לבוא בטענות על סמך חכמה בדיעבד. הבאתי כמה תגובות למעלה תגובה 724329 את דו"ח מרכז המידע והידע הלאומי למערכה בקורונה מיום 20.6 אה, סליחה, זה היה בתגובה שענית עליה בלי לקרוא אותה. אז תקרא עכשיו. הם צפו את זה, ועוד איך! ביום 20.6 היו בארץ 20,679 מקרים ו 308 מקרי מוות במצטבר. בימים ההם כבר חזרנו לקצב גידול של מעל 200 מקרים ביום, לעומת קצב של 20 מקרים ביום בשפל של אמצע מאי. ואיפה ישיבת הממשלה הדחופה בנושא? ישיבות הממשלה מתקיימות מדי יום ראשון. ביום ראשון 21.6 אף תגובה, ביום ראשון 28.6 במהלך ישיבת הממשלה, הודיע ראש הממשלה כי קבינט הקורונה צפוי לאשר הגבלות חדשות. ישיבת קבינט הקורונה הסתיימה ללא החלטות. נקבע דיון נוסף למחר. האם הוצג לקבינט הקורונה דו"ח מרכז המידע והידע הלאומי למערכה בקורונה? אנחנו לא יודעים. ביום 2.7 התקיימה ישיבת ממשלה סוערת ובסיומה הודיעו נתניהו ואדלשטיין על מגבלות של התכנסות עד 50 איש. אז כבר הגענו ל 800 מקרים חדשים ביום. ראה גם את תגובה 721468 שלי שמופנית אליך מיום 6/7 ובה אני מפרט דברים שצריך וניתן היה לעשות. |
|
||||
|
||||
זו אותה טקטיקה ישנה שמסבירה מדוע ממשלות ימין אף פעם לא טועות. אם קורה משהו טוב, אז ביבי והימין הראו לכולם איך דברים צריכים להעשות. עוד הוכחה לכך שאידיאולוגית הימין היא נכונה. אם קורה משהו רע, אז ביבי והימין נכנעו לשמאל שיודע רק להפריע, לציבור חלש האופי או לשופטים נודניקים. קשה להאשים בכך את ביבי. עוד הוכחה לכך שאידיאולוגית הימין היא נכונה. לממשלות ימין אין אחריות על מה שקורה בעולם האמיתי. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני לא רואה איך ימין ושמאל קשור כאן. הממשלה לא מתפקדת לא בגלל שהיא ממשלת ימין או שמאל, אלא משום שיש בה רוב (ובראשו ראש הממשלה) שלא שם את טובת המדינה במקום הראשון. |
|
||||
|
||||
הממשלה היא ממשלת ימין + פוליטיקאים עלובי נפש מסורסים ופחדנים מכחול לבן. במילים אחרות - ממשלת ימין. די כבר עם הביבי ביבי ביבי. אי אפשר להאשים את ביבי שהוא דואג רק לעצמו כשהוא מגובה ברוב של חברי כנסת שדואגים רק לעצמו1. בוודאי שימין מול שמאל זה הנושא. גם אתה נדבקת במחלת ה״מחאה א-פוליטית״? כל המחדל לא מתחיל או נגמר בביבי. הפלונטר הפוליטי בישראל (והסיבה לכוחו הבלתי ניתן לפיצוח של ביבי גם כשהרוב לא מרוצה מתפקודו) זה שיש לציבור הישראלי אלרגיה ל״שמאל״ וערבים ולכן הוא מוכן להתעלם מכל מחדל של ממשלת ימין כי ״מה האלטרנטיבה שלך?! טיבי?!״. ביבי לא יצר את גל הרקבון של הדמוקרטיה הישראלית. ביבי רק גולש עליו. _________ 1 לא שגיאת כתיב. |
|
||||
|
||||
אני מסכים בהחלט עם המשפט האחרון, ועדיין לא מבין את הקשר ימין-שמאל. 1. אין שמאל יותר1. רק השוליים הסהרוריים נותרו ממנו. לכן כל ממשלה תהיה ממשלת ימין. 2. כנוי הגנאי "שמאלני" מוטח בימנים כשרים רק משום שהעזו לנקוט בעמדות ליברליות המזוהות עם מפלגת החירות עליה השלום (דן מרידור, רובי ריבלין, בני בגין). האלרגיה היא לא לשמאל אלא ל"אסמול" הדמוני והדמיוני. הימין מגדיר את עצמו כניגוד של שמאל מומצא (גנץ. שמאל. חלש.) 3. מסע ההכפשות נגד התקשורת ובתי המשפט (השמאלנים, כתיב הליברלים) הוא יצירה שלנתניהו זכויות יוצרים על הלחנתה, גם אם יש לה מבצעים רבים. אגב, כשאמרתי לשני מכרים ממוצא רוסי (בשתי הזדמנויות שונות) שמה שאני מוחה עליו הוא שהממשלה תתחיל לדאוג למדינה, התגובה שלהם היתה זהה- אתה מבקש הרבה. זה הפטליזם הרוסי, ונראה לי ששכבות רחבות בעם לוקות בוריאציות שלו. _________ 1 לפיד זה שמאל כמו שאני צנצנת. |
|
||||
|
||||
1. יש שמאל. פשוט לא אוהבים את המותג אז מתחבאים מאחורי המושג ״מרכז״. 2. נכון. זה בדיוק העניין. השמאל האמיתי כל כך נבהל מהפגיעה במותג שלו עם ״אסמול״ המומצא שהוא מנסה כל הזמן למתג את עצמו מחדש כ״מרכז פוליטי״ באיזו תקווה שיצליח לקחת קולות לגוש הימין. 3. זה לא משנה מה נתניהו רוצה או עושה. זה משנה מי נותן לו את הכוח לעשות זאת ומי שנותן לו את הכוח זה חברי הכנסת של קואליצית התועבה, כולל חברי הכנסת האיומים ביותר שהיו למדינת ישראל אי פעם - אנשי כחול לבן שעושים קולות של שטיח. לפיד זה שמאל מדיני ציוני מתון כמו מפלגת העבודה של רבין, אז מסתבר שאתה בהחלט צנצנת. זה שהליכוד אימץ עמדות מדיניות שלפני שני עשורים נחשבו הצד השמאלי של מפלגת העבודה (או שמאלה מכך), זה לא אומר שלפיד זה לא שמאל. הימין זז שמאלה עם השנים וזה כל הסיפור (אחת הסיבות למה כל כך היה חשוב לו להמציא את ״אסמול״ הדמיוני לצרכי אי פגיעה במותג ״ימין״). |
|
||||
|
||||
ראה תגובתי לפונז תגובה 690107 וכן תגובה 709223 |
|
||||
|
||||
ולמה שמתי את זה כאן? כי אם הגרף שלך יתחיל לרדת מחר אני אגיד שזה בזכותי! |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x410 19.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.....401 20..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......403 21......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.............390 22..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.............398 |
|
||||
|
||||
גרף 22....................x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................20
23........................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................24 24...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 25....................................ox.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 26.........................................xo................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 27...............................................o.x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 28..................................................x....o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 29.................................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................66 30............................................................................o...x..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................80 31...................................................................................x..o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 01..............................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................94 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 04...................................................................................................................x...o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................115 05...............................................................................................................................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................127 06............................................................................................................................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 07...................................................................................................................................................o.....x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................153 08...................................................................................................................................................x.......o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................147 09...............................................................................................................................................................o.....x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................165 10....................................................................................................................................................................x.....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................164 11.............................................................................................................................................................................o......x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................180 12..............................................................................................................................................................................x...o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 13...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 14...................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................181 15................................................................................................................................................................................xo.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................176 16..............................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................174 17..............................................................................................................................................................................o.......x....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................182 18.......................................................................................................................................................................xo..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................167 19............................................................................................................................................................x.o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................156 20.....................................................................................................................................................ox....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................150 21..............................................................................................................................................x....o.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................142 22..............................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................148 23........................................................................................................................................x....o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................136 24.......................................................................................................................................o...x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................139 25..................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 26..................................................................................................................................o.x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................132 27..............................................................................................................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................129 28.....................................................................................................................x....o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 29......................................................................................................................o.x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................120 30..................................................................................................................o..x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................117 01.........................................................................................................x....o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................105 02.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 03.....................................................................................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................103 04.............................................................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................93 05.........................................................................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 06.......................................................................................o..x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07...................................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................83 08.............................................................................x..o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................77 09.............................................................................o...x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................81 10..........................................................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 11.......................................................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................73 12...................................................................o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................67 13.............................................................x.o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................61 14.............................................................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................62 15............................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................60 16...........................................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 17..........................................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................59 18........................................................ox.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................57 19...................................................x.o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................51 20.................................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................50 21..............................................x.o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 22...............................................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 23..............................................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................47 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 26..........................................ox...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.......................................x.o.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 28.......................................o.x.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 29.....................................x.o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 30......................................ox...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 31.....................................o.x...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 01.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 02...............................o............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 03............................xo.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................28 04...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 05.............................ox............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................30 06.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 07............................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 08...........................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................27 09.............................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................29 10..............................ox...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 11...............................xo..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................31 12.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 13.................................xo........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................33 14.................................ox........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................34 15................................x.o........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................32 16...................................ox......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................36 17.....................................o......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................37 18.......................................o....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................39 19........................................o...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 20........................................xo.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................40 21...........................................o................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 22............................................o.x............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 23..........................................x.o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................42 24.............................................o..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 25..............................................o..x.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................49 26...........................................xo..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................43 27.........................................x.o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................41 28............................................ox.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................45 29..............................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 30..............................................x..o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................46 01.....................................................o..x..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................56 02..........................................................x....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................58 03........................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................74 04.................................................................................o..x......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................84 05......................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................86 06........................................................................................o.x................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................90 07.........................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................89 08.........................................................................................................o.x...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................107 09......................................................................................................................o.....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................118 10...............................................................................................................................o..x........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................130 11......................................................................................................................................xo...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................134 12.............................................................................................................................................x...o.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................141 13...............................................................................................................................................................ox..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................160 14.................................................................................................................................................................................o..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................177 15................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................195 16............................................................................................................................................................................................................o...............................................................................................................................................................................................................204 17...................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x.....................................................................................................................................................................................................213 18.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................................................................................................................................................................................217 19..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.............................................................................................................................................................................238 20............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x.......................................................................................................................................................259 21...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox......................................................................................................................................................260 22...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...........o...........................................................................................................................................259 23.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x...................................................................................................................295 24..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........................................................................................................302 25........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.o................................................................................................312 26...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x.................................................................................329 27.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................................................................................317 28................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox.........................................................................................321 29..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o....................................................................................322 30......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.........x..........................................................................336 31...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x........o..................................................................................319 01........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo.................................................................................328 02..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x......................................................................340 03..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.....................................................................334 04..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.............................................................349 05..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......................................................355 06.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x............o....................................................345 07.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x....................................374 08..................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o..x.....................389 09.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ox................394 10.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.....x.............397 11.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x....o........................381 12...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o............................379 13.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x........................386 14.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x.....o...........................377 15...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o........................387 16..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o.x..............396 17..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x..o.........398 18...................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o......x410 19.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...o.....401 20..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................o....x.......403 21......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x......o.............390 22..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................xo...........398 23........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................x...408 |
חזרה לעמוד הראשי |
מערכת האייל הקורא אינה אחראית לתוכן תגובות שנכתבו בידי קוראים | |
RSS מאמרים | כתבו למערכת | אודות האתר | טרם התעדכנת | ארכיון | חיפוש | עזרה | תנאי שימוש | © כל הזכויות שמורות |