There is no communism in the childish way that you perceive reality in. Real changes in class society only acore by violent means. India, south Africa and the condition of the black population in the u.s. are the best examples to the fact that without a revolution and state power, the proletarian will always find himself at the same position. Your racist government would have never realize that there is Palestinian people in the so called state of israel, if the Palestinian would not have started fighting for their rights. The need for a revolution and the dictatorship of the proletarian is forced on the proletarian by the condition that exists in capitalism. Do you think that after a revolution in Palestine all those brainwashed settlers that your government uses as shock troops against the Palestinian, (just like the hagana used the etzel and lehi to assassinate and evict Palestinians) would accept loosing their dreams of an all Jewish and fascist israel? Or all those religious fundamentalists would accept laws who give women the same rights as men? And your country's "best friend", do you think that the u.s. would just seat aside while their army base in the middle east is being diminished? Or on another level would you let Jewish families to vote if they want to send their kids to integrated schools? Or to go integrated jobs? Or more fundamentally to lose their privilege, and become equal to Arabs? The dictatorship of the proletarian is a necessary need by the unsane conditions that are created under capitalism. And no, all those people would not be send to an education camp. But the politics and the direction of the state would be dictate. Opposition would be encourage (just like in revolutionary china), but if those forces try to kill the revolution they would be crushed.
I feel however that this discussion for you is not about what is the best way to help humanity (since you never came up with a solution of your own) and its more about protecting your privilege as a Jewish woman in Palestine.
|